Test the pencil

-
(Not to be mistaken for the pencil test)
 If the requirement for a pencil was to write 10 pages, and during testing the pencil ended up writing 12 pages.
What should the testers do? Pass it or fail?
Should the testers PASS the pencil test because the result was better than expected?
Should the testers FAIL the pencil test because the result was not per spec?
May the testers ask for more specs regarding the weight and thickness of the overall pencil?
May the testers ask for more specs regarding the weight and thickness of the lead core?
Should the testers re-test the darkness of the writing?
Should the testers use other kinds of paper for executing re-testing?
What would you do as a tester?
Why should you do anything else besides testing and giving a pass or fail?



Possible defects – 
  1. Longer pencil than mentioned in spec
  2. Thinner lead core than mentioned in spec;

Possible concerns – 
  1. More money is being spent on the pencil
  2. Less return of investment may be the result.

A few opinions I collected over the years - 
  1. Need more clarification and information
  2. It is a FAIL because the company could be losing its return on investment.
  3. It is a PASS because more the merrier
  4. When the requirement was to test till 10 pages, the tester should have stopped testing at 10 pages. The extra testing is exhaustive testing. We should limit our tests to the resources we are provided only.
What would you suggest and do, if you faced such a situation?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Testers Life

-
Image
There is a plethora of examples explaining about a Developer's life. It is time to show the QA in the same "light". I am a QA and only some of these are my experiences. Which ones can you relate to? This is what they think QA are like This is what we wish QA could be like My first day on the job - I am introduced. Product training for QA I am trying to find my way through SharePoint It has always been like this. It's not a bug, don't log a ticket for it, the existing QA tell me. (Or maybe they do not want to admit that they missed a big fucking bug.) This is how Devs are trained about the project. This is how QAs are trained about the project I finally get my build to test. It is 5:00 pm Friday I am not given access to anything, but I am expected to test Setting up Test Data Smoke Testing (it usually never detects the fire or smoke till we get to production and a customer reports it. But it sounds good.) Trying to
Read more

Lots of Work

-
Image
“Working so hard” “There is a lot of work to do” “Such a big application” “So many bugs”  "Too much work load"  "Not enough time" What should it really mean to the person hearing it? – Nothing. I have seen members take loads of work and not bat an eye and do it with ease. I have also seen members take little work and make it look big and stress out and stress others out. I have also seen organizations that plan and work smart. I have seen organizations that plan to work really, really hard. I am not here to explain the right way of doing things. Whatever floats your boat!! Lol But, when people talk about a lot of work, it reminds me of the Woody Allen movie – Annie Hall There is a scene in the movie with a psychiatrist. The conversation goes like this - Alvy's psychiatrist : How often do you sleep together? Annie's psychiatrist : Do you have sex often? Alvy Singer : Hardly ever. Maybe three times a week.
Read more

Vanilla Ice Cream caused General motors to not start

-
Vanilla Ice Cream that puzzled General motors’!!!! An Interesting Story Never underestimate your Clients' Complaint, no matter how funny it might seem! This is a real story that happened between the customer of General Motors and its Customer-Care Executive. Pls read on..... A complaint was received by the Pontiac Division of General Motors: 'This is the second time I have written to you, and I don't blame you for not answering me, because I sounded crazy, but it is a fact that we have a tradition in our family of Ice-Cream for dessert after dinner each night, but the kind of ice cream varies so, every night, after we've eaten, the whole family votes on which kind of ice cream we should have and I drive down to the store to get it. It's also a fact that I recently purchased a new Pontiac and since then my trips to the store have created a problem..... You see, every time I buy a vanilla ice-cream, when I start back from the store my car won
Read more